Post updated April, 11, 2019
This is my take on Newman’s Own Southwest Dressing Recipe. Just like McDonald’s southwest salad dressing you can make at home.
On our way back to Minnesota from Florida, MaryJo and I make some quick stops for lunch. My favorite quick stop is McDonald’s to get a Southwest salad with grilled chicken. McDonald’s are at every other interchange and you know what you are getting when you buy there.
I don’t know if you are familiar with this, but it is a big salad with iceberg lettuce, cilantro, corn, black beans, grated cheddar cheese, topped with spicy tortilla chips with a packet of Newman’s Own Southwest Restaurant Dressing. It is a really delicious, low calorie lunch which really hits the spot. Thing is, Newman’s own Southwest Dressing is not sold in stores. Bummer! The Southwest Dressing Recipe is a total secret and you can’t buy it.
Developing the Southwest Dressing Recipe
While we were at one of the McDonald stops I told MaryJo that I should try to duplicate the recipe for the Southwest Dressing, so I took a picture of the ingredient label. Logical first step.
There were things like corn syrup solids, corn vinegar, cornstarch, whey, and sour cream powder. Curious ingredients. I’m sure that if you are Paul Newman you could call up friends and have this stuff delivered to your front step! No problem.
Well I am Joe and not Paul and have no idea what this stuff is. So I experiment.
One of the ingredients is egg yolks mixed with soybean oil and cider vinegar. The egg yolks make the oil and vinegar mix together to make an emulsion that will not separate, (the old oil and water thing). Well I throw this together and added the spices I thought were in the dressing and made a pretty good likeness to the original, (not really). Then I make another blend. Not quite right.
By then I’m thinking that if I come up with a copycat recipe, it would contain uncooked eggs. Salmonella city!
I went back to the store and bought pasteurized eggs. Turns out they are hard to separate, yolks and whites, but I got the job done. I then tried another spice blend and I was not close again.
MaryJo sensed my frustration and suggested that I use already processed oil, water and eggs…Mayonnaise. I thought. okay, I give up.
So, with a new sense of purpose and determination, I tried at least 5 more spice blends which required MaryJo to go to the store once and for me to go to the store once more,for spices that we would try and to get more sour cream since I used all that we had.
Finally, the blend of spices worked and my Southwest Dressing Recipe is pretty close to Paul’s. He must have spent a lot of time perfecting these recipes! His is exceptional but mine is dang good.
You can’t buy his except at McDonald’s, or you can make your own which is nearly as good. My recipe makes enough for two salads, but if you enjoy this southwest dressing recipe, feel free to double or triple the ingredients. It should store in the refrigerator for two or three weeks.
Try it. You won’t be disappointed.
Hey. Did you make this recipe? Let me know how you liked it in the comments below. Take a photo of your creation and post it on your Instagram…and hashtag #joeshealthymeals so I can take a look.
Southwest Dressing Recipe
Ingredients
- 2 tbsp mayonnaise
- 1 tbsp sour cream
- 2 tsp light Karo syrup (agave or honey as substitutes)
- 1 tsp water (or more to thin)
- 1/2 tsp cider vinegar
- 1/2 tsp lime juice
- 1/4 tsp onion powder
- 1/4 tsp garlic powder
- 1/2 tsp dried cilantro
- 1 tsp McCormick hot mexican style chili powder
- 1/4 tsp cayenne pepper
- 1/2 tsp cumin
Salad
- iceburg lettuce
- cilantro
- red onion
- corn
- black beans
- grape tomatoes
- thin sliced carrot
- grated cheddar cheese
- Mrs. Cubbison's southwest flavor tortilla strips ,
Instructions
- Whisk ingredients in a medium sized bowl
- Refrigerate to store
Notes
This recipe makes 4 1/2 tbsp or approximately 2, 1 1/4 fl. oz. servings
Nutrition
I only made the dressing but it was really good! Thanks!
Delicious dressing! I’ve never actually had Newman’s Own Southwest Dressing lol…but avocados are in season and a salad sounded really good, so here we are. I made a double batch just to make sure my husband and I had enough dressing for two big dinner salads. I used half the corn syrup and I think it’s sweet enough for me. Also only used half the cayenne pepper and it’s got a good kick but I wouldn’t want it spicier. Thanks for the recipe!
I am Canadian so there are no Southwest salads at Canadian McDonalds😟😟😟😟
I have made your dressing many times in many quantities and am asked to bring it to group events all the time. Thank you for doing all the experimenting! Not sure I would have that much patience!
Thanks Mary. I’m humbled by your comment.
I cannot thank you enough! For years I was so disappointed that I couldn’t actually buy this which is one of my all time favorite dressings. I just made it. PERFECT! Thank you so much kind sir!
Thanks Angie.
Delicious, and thanks for sharing. Easy to make and was spot on with the taste. This recipe is a keeper.
Thanks Alberta…glad you like it.
Wow you really did get that spice thing down. Brilliant recipe! Will use it often.
Thanks LaDonna!
Making it yourself you can tailor to your tastes. It is as good as Mr. Newman’s. I’m used agave, fresh cilantro and Kewpie mayonnaise. This recipe is a great discovery. Thanks for publishing it.
Thanks for finding my recipe Ed, and thanks for the nice comment. It’s very appreciated.
Thank you for all your hard work and sharing! This is delicious!
Thanks Denise!
I love the southwestern salad at McDonald’s. It’s the Only thing I eat from there. I hate that we can’t buy the dressing in the store.
Thanks for sharing. I do hate onions, so I’ll leave them out. 😍
Hope you like the dressing Angie.
I’ve never tasted Paul Newman’s but this was very good. I always regret adding sweetener to a recipe so I didn’t use it and it was fine. I subbed the sour cream for plain greek yogurt as that’s what I had on hand. I added a little bit of salt.
Thank you! My 14 year old daughter loves this salad and knows I only make our salad dressings from scratch, so she searched and found this recipe. Big hit in our house. A keeper!
Thanks for the nice comment Dawn.
Just made your salad dressing. I didn’t have sour cream so i melted cream cheese in its stead. I used half fresh and half dried cilantro. It came out fantastic!! I love the Paul Newman’s now i can make it at home thanks to you!! It is delicious. Thanks again for your recipe.
Thanks for the comment Christine. Glad you like it.
I can’t wait to try this! I’m also wondering if you’ve attempted the other sauce that’s already in the salad before adding dressing. It’s kind of a clearish color. And the corn/bean mixture seems to have some kind of sauce with it too. All I know is that salad has SO MUCH FLAVOR. I’m going to start working on building this salad at home, for sure. Thank you!
Thanks for making me a hero at dinner tonight! We loved this dressing. I topped the salad with cilantro lime marinated chicken. This is a real keeper! Thanks!
Thanks for the comment Sandy. Glad you liked it.
Absolutely awesome recipe! Thanks!! I added a little bit of smoked paprika. Yum!!!!
Thanks Jayme. Glad you liked it.